CT1905

Stool: Clostridium difficile common antigen and toxin/toxin gene

CT1905A: Positive/Positive    CT1905B: Positive/Positive

CMPT QA/QC

CT1905-A: C.difficile common antigen positive and gene/toxin positive, viable for 51 days

CT1905-B: C.difficile common antigen positive and gene/toxin positive, viable for 51 days

Reference Laboratories

CT1905-A: 9/12 laboratories reported common antigen and toxin positive; 3 laboratories reported only toxin positive and did not test common antigen. 12/12 laboratories indicated they would report to IC/PH.

CT1905-B: 9/12 laboratories reported common antigen and toxin positive; 3 laboratories reported only toxin positive and did not test common antigen. 12/12 laboratories indicated they would report to IC/PH.

Participants’ results

Table 1. CT1905A - Antigen/Toxin or Toxin geneTotalGrade
Positive/Positive52Acceptable/Acceptable
Not tested/Positive6Ungraded/Acceptable
Total58

Table 2. CT1905A - IC /PH NotificationTotalGrade
Yes57Acceptable
No1Unacceptable
Total58

Table 3. CT1905B - Antigen/Toxin or Toxin geneTotalGrade
Positive/Positive52Acceptable/Acceptable
Not tested/Positive6Ungraded/Acceptable
Total58

Table 4. CT1905B - IC /PH NotificationTotalGrade
Yes56Acceptable
No2Unacceptable
Total58

NT: not tested

Suitability for Grading

A challenge is considered suitable for grading if agreement is reached by 80 percent of selected reference group and at least 70 percent of the participants.

Antigen and toxin detection was correctly performed by at least 80 percent of reference laboratories and greater than 70 percent of all laboratories thus, both challenges were determined to be suitable for grading.

Grading: Please note that grading for Clostridium difficile toxin testing has changed. Please click here for more details

The samples are assessed for homogeneity and stability using in-house quality control methods and random selection of samples before and during production, and post sample delivery. The number of random samples selected is based on selection tables within Military standard 105E (1).

The challenge sample lot was confirmed to be homogeneous and stable for at least 15 days.

Grading of Clostridium difficile common antigen and toxin/toxin gene detection is based on a Positive / Negative result, no further statistical analysis is performed on the results beyond that described under “Suitability for grading(1) Famum NR. Acceptance sampling. In: Modern Statistical Quality Control and Improvement. Belmont, California.: Duxbury Press; 1994:305.

Posted in CDNews, Clostridium difficile Results, critiques